the unseen world and other essays-第32章
按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
to strengthen it by the very persons to whom the interests of religion are presumed to be a professional care。 It is nevertheless a very superficial conception； and no book which is vitiated by it can have much philosophic value。 It is simply the crude impression which； in minds unaccustomed to analysis； is left by the fact that theologians and other persons interested in religion are usually alarmed at new scientific truths； and resist them with emotions so highly wrought that they are not only incapable of estimating evidence； but often also have their moral sense impaired； and fight with foul means when fair ones fail。 If we reflect carefully on this class of phenomena； we shall see that something besides mere pride of opinion is involved in the struggle。 At the bottom of changing theological beliefs there lies something which men perennially value； and for the sake of which they cling to the beliefs as long as possible。 That which they value is not itself a matter of belief； but it is a matter of conduct； it is the searching after goodness；after a higher life than the mere satisfaction of individual desires。 All animals seek for fulness of life； but in civilized man this craving has acquired a moral significance； and has become a spiritual aspiration； and this emotional tendency； more or less strong in the human race； we call religious feeling or religion。 Viewed in this light； religion is not only something that mankind is never likely to get rid of； but it is incomparably the most noble as well as the most useful attribute of humanity。
Now； this emotional prompting toward completeness of life requires； of course； that conduct should be guided； as far as possible； in accordance with a true theory of the relations of man to the world in which he lives。 Hence； at any given era the religious feeling will always be found enlisted in behalf of some theory of the universe。 At any time； whatever may be their shortcomings in practice； religious men will aim at doing right according to their conceptions of the order of the world。 If men's conceptions of the order of nature remained constant； no apparent conflict between their religious feelings and their knowledge need ever arise。 But with the first advance in our knowledge of nature the case is altered。 New and strange theories are naturally regarded with fear and dislike by persons who have always been accustomed to find the sanction and justification of their emotional prompting toward righteousness in old familiar theories which the new ones are seeking to supplant。 Such persons oppose the new doctrine because their engrained mental habits compel them to believe that its establishment will in some way lower men's standard of life； and make them less careful of their spiritual welfare。 This is the case； at all events； when theologians oppose scientific conclusions on religious grounds； and not simply from mental dulness or rigidity。 And； in so far as it is religious feeling which thus prompts resistance to scientific innovation； it may be said； with some appearance of truth； that there is a conflict between religion and science。
But there must always be two parties to a quarrel； and our statement has to be modified as soon as we consider what the scientific innovator impugns。 It is not the emotional prompting toward righteousness； it is not the yearning to live im Guten； Ganzen； Wahren； that he seeks to weaken； quite likely he has all this as much at heart as the theologian who vituperates him。 Nor is it true that his discoveries； in spite of him； tend to destroy this all…important mental attitude。 It would be ridiculous to say that the fate of religious feeling is really involved in the fate of grotesque cosmogonies and theosophies framed in the infancy of men's knowledge of nature； for history shows us quite the contrary。 Religious feeling has survived the heliocentric theory and the discoveries of geologists； and it will be none the worse for the establishment of Darwinism。 It is the merest truism to say that religion strikes its roots deeper down into human nature than speculative opinion； and is accordingly independent of any particular set of beliefs。 Since； then； the scientific innovator does not； either voluntarily or involuntarily； attack religion； it follows that there can be no such 〃conflict〃 as that of which Dr。 Draper has undertaken to write the history。 The real contest is between one phase of science and another； between the more…crude knowledge of yesterday and the less…crude knowledge of to…day。 The contest； indeed； as presented in history； is simply the measure of the difficulty which men find in exchanging old views for new ones。 All along； the practical question has been； whether we should passively acquiesce in the crude generalizations of our ancestors or venture actively to revise them。 But as for the religious sentiment； the perennial struggle in which it has been engaged has not been with scientific inquiry； but with the selfish propensities whose tendency is to make men lead the lives of brutes。
The time is at hand when the interests of religion can no longer be supposed to be subserved by obstinate adherence to crude speculations bequeathed to us from pre…scientific antiquity。 One good result of the doctrine of evolution； which is now gaining sway in all departments of thought； is the lesson that all our opinions must be held subject to continual revision； and that with none of them can our religious interests be regarded as irretrievably implicated。 To any one who has once learned this lesson； a book like Dr。 Draper's can be neither interesting nor useful。 He who has not learned it can derive little benefit from a work which in its very title keeps open an old and baneful source of error and confusion。
November。 1875。
VII。 NATHAN THE WISE。＇28＇
＇28＇ Nathan the Wise： A Dramatic Poem； by Gotthold Ephraim Lessing。 Translated by Ellen Frothingham。 Preceded by a brief account of the poet and his works； and followed by an essay on the poem by Kuno Fischer。 Second edition。 New York： Leypoldt & Holt。 1868。
Le Christianisme Moderne。 etude sur Lessing。 Par Ernest Fontanes。 Paris： Bailliere。 1867。
The fame of Lessing is steadily growing。 Year by year he is valued more highly； and valued by a greater number of people。 And he is destined； like his master and forerunner Spinoza； to receive a yet larger share of men's reverence and gratitude when the philosophic spirit which he lived to illustrate shall have become in some measure the general possession of the civilized part of mankind。 In his own day； Lessing； though widely known and greatly admired； was little understood or appreciated。 He was known to be a learned antiquarian； a terrible controversialist； and an incomparable writer。 He was regarded as a brilliant ornament to Germany； and a paltry Duke of Brunswick thought a few hundred thalers well spent in securing the glory of having such a man to reside at his provincial court。 But the majority of Lessing's contemporaries understood him as little perhaps as did the Duke of Brunswick。 If anything were needed to prove this； it would he the uproar which was made over the publication of the 〃Wolfenbuttel Fragments；〃 and the curious exegesis which was applied to the poem of 〃Nathan〃 on its first appearance。 In order to understand the true character of this great poem； and of Lessing's religious opinions as embodied in it； it will be necessary first to consider the memorable theological controversy which preceded it。
During Lessing's residence at Hamburg； he had come into possession of a most important manuscript； written by Hermann Samuel Reimarus； a professor of Oriental languages； and bearing the title of an 〃Apology for the Rational Worshippers of God。〃 Struck with the rigorous logic displayed in its arguments； and with the quiet dignity of its style； while yet unable to accept its most general conclusions； Lessing resolved to publish the manuscript； accompanying it with his own comments and strictures。 Accordingly in 1774； availing himself of the freedom from censorship enjoyed by publications drawn from manuscripts deposited in the Ducal Library at Wolfenbuttel； of which he was librarian； Lessing published the first portion of thi
